This week's bake with the
Rose's Alpha Bakers is
Hamantaschen, small cookies eaten during the Jewish holiday Purim (
learn more about Purim). Hamantaschen are traditionally made with a poppyseed filling, however I like to save my poppyseed-eating for cakes and muffins so I improvised and did more of a rugelach-type filling. In all seriousness, I like poppyseeds - but not that much - so I thought a cookie filled with poppyseed paste would be too overpowering.
My poor little Hamantaschen - which were supposed to bake up in a cute little triangle shape - were a complete fail. They
all opened during baking so I ended up with more of an open-faced mini mince pie cookie. I followed the directions exactly in terms of the chilling of the dough, the rolling of the dough (thickness and size of the cookie), and I don't think I overfilled them, so I'm at a loss of what went wrong. Maybe I should have used a folded over corner instead of pinching them closed.
I also wish I had mixed up the apricot lekvar with the nuts, raisins and cinnamon-sugar so it all melted together better, but...oh well. Even if they don't look the way they should, they were tasty.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/28aae/28aae720f4edcb7b87793b73a3c15af60ded2dd0" alt="" |
you can see the flaky pâte sucrée crust... |
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/82dc0/82dc0858a08a0c5fe654537fc05bb6be8ec3a8d8" alt="" |
...but they are all flat flat flat...boo hoo! |
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/98e08/98e08e97987beb8f5c38a7371e345ba63ef19924" alt="" |
mise en place for the cookie crust |
I prefer to make my pie crusts by hand rather than in the food processor as instructed in the recipe (seems easier to get a real feel for the dough, you don't over-work the crust, and you don't have to wash the food processor bowl and blade afterward). It's easy to do by hand - just go fast and keep your hands well covered in flour (so their heat doesn't melt the butter). This cookie dough was actually a pâte sucrée crust, which has sugar and an egg yolk, so it's a sweeter and more sturdy dough than regular pie crust.
In these first four photos I'm incorporating the butter into the flour-sugar mixture. In the next four, I've added the cream and egg yolk and am forming the dough. The dough is then divided and given a rest in the fridge before rolling it out.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2c8f8/2c8f8f77293893b38c848ad5babfe150622dc326" alt="" |
incorporating the butter |
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/fc9dd/fc9dded0f4ad96646448d129aa346cfff64c3ce9" alt="" |
finishing the dough |
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/85f26/85f26d460e700f017c8383547b05c8b4e2094f5c" alt="" |
filling for the cookies |
Rose raves about muscovado sugar - and uses it in many recipes - so I bought a 2-pack of huge(!) tubs of
light muscovado sugar from Amazon.com. It was a bit expensive - for sugar - but much, much cheaper than buying the small packs available at the grocery store.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8e3be/8e3be1cc00ba75e45a68840d55d93b1ebd53a44e" alt="" |
smells delicious! |
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3a8a2/3a8a28e54a9cd66453476650e69648fb2e4f091c" alt="" |
cutting out my cookie rounds |
I wish I knew what went wrong. Maybe I left the openings too large? Maybe I should have sealed the edges with water instead of an egg wash? Too much filling? All of the above?
They are a bit more open than the pictures in the cookbook, but I pinched those edges pretty good! Oh well. I'll just pretend I did it on purpose...mini open-faced mince pies ;)
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8fafb/8fafbe3e764e853b283f02364aeb585349a67de7" alt="" |
cookies assembled, given an eggwash, and chilled |
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/96857/96857850a20f719c68cad70bbcc7cee8e5e8f369" alt="" |
a close-up |
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2ae17/2ae1721cbb7a67f94c5c7d6b3568911f9c61310f" alt="" |
every single one opened back up... |
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5fa05/5fa05d41406676ceaf41b1e0c8771b020d092a6b" alt="" |
mini open-faced mince pies |
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cf5f0/cf5f04c6240f2c76176327c7f8702220c35985b4" alt="" |
still delicious! |
Bye for now...
Did you chill the shaped cookies before baking? I like your rugelach filling. I'm not a fan of the poppy seed filling - they taste too strong. I'll try the rugelach filling next time.
ReplyDeleteHi Jenn, yep, chilled before baking and they still popped open. Definitely try the rugelach filling - it was good.
DeleteThat's what happened to mine the last time I made them. This time I folded the cookie dough over tightly so there was just a little space in the middle before I baked them. Then they opened up a little when I baked them.
ReplyDeleteThanks Marie - I'll definitely try to fold them tightly next time. I thought the pinched corners would be nicer, but folded it better than open-faced!
DeleteRound or triangle they sound delicious with your filling!
ReplyDeleteThanks Vicki!
DeleteRugelach filling is a great idea! Even though they opened up, they still looked good. It looked like you did that intentionally! I like how the fillings sit on top of a round pastry.
ReplyDeleteThanks! It is funny how the topping didn't spread (because it sure did when I made rugelach!).
Deletewell I bet they still tasted great. My first batch I shaped them as I used to do it with my mom and they came out great, but than I decided to follow rose instruction and i had many of them opened up, and when i tried to re- shape them they seemed to break down. yet your cookies looks great.
ReplyDeleteForget about how they look, they sound wonderful. I would have loved your filling much more than the options given in the book. If you get a chance, I hope you'll stop by and see my post.
ReplyDeletePatricia @ ButterYum
http://www.butteryum.org/roses-alpha-bakers/2015/2/11/tbb-hamantaschen-purim
Hi Alice: Well, the mystery of the opening Hamantaschen...but I'm sure they were delicious anyway! Great step by step photos.
ReplyDelete